I posted earlier on these under-rated lures, and thought I would add a little bit to my previous post to give you a better understanding on how and why these lures were not as prevalent as their Creek Chub mainline brothers. Let’s take a peek at the production records from the Creek Chub archives, to see how many were produced.
The Shur Strike Darter was produced from 1939-1944, and came back in the 50’s for Montgomery Wards, but just the Frog color from catalogs I have seen. I have production records from 1940-1944, so lets take a look at what was produced during that time span by color.
0 Pikie 451
1 Peanut Butter 448
1YP Perch 922
2 Red White 263
5 Red Side 33
6 Shiner Scale 79
8 Rainbow 189
11 Black White 18
14 Chain Perch 255
18 Silver Flash 1174
19 Frog 14163
Yellow Spotted 40
Not surprising, Frog was the dominate color, just like the main Creek Chub line. Keep in mind Frog was available in two shades, a dark green, and a light green frog. The Dark Frog was earlier and the light Frog was later, and was used when they started selling to Wards in the 50’s.
You may wonder why these totals were so low, when Creek Chub produced hundreds of thousands during this span of the main line Darter. I think the biggest reason would be that they did not want to compete against such a successful lure. Most of the catalog companies that Creek Chub sold the Shur Strike line, did not offer the Darter. I would assume it was a marketing decision by Creek Chub to sell some of the other styles. The Bass Oreno and River Runt styles did not compete against the main line, and were almost always sold to the retailers and wholesalers. Another reason may be that the Shur Strike style did not work as well, but that discussion will be tabled for a later day.
I also wanted to point out that Red and White is really a scarce model to find when you consider that it was very popular in the main line. Perch is also difficult to find, along with Chain Perch, and Red Side. Black and White and Yellow Spotted are listed above, but I have never seen them cataloged.
I addressed some of the body style differences in my previous post, but I did want to mention that the flat part of the head can vary somewhat. I have two lures that I have found with a more rounded head and have less of the V point head as you can see in the picture below.
If you find a Darter in a color that is not listed above, you will have found a real jewel! Keep on the look out, as these are not always properly identified! Here’s a Green Scale I found that I have never seen listed!